Testimonials & Reviews
Orthopedic Specialists
Orthopedic Surgeons located in Palm Harbor, FL
Orthopedic Specialists always appreciates feedback from our valued patients. To date, we’re thrilled to have collected 3940 reviews with an average rating of 4.93 out of 5 stars. Please read what others are saying about Orthopedic Specialists below, and as always, we would love to collect your feedback.
Bruce B.
Submitted 07/10/25
Dr Brotherton explained my diagnosis in detail and answered all my questions regarding the procedure .
I look forward to the followup care that he will provide .
Pamela S.
Submitted 07/10/25
As always great friendly service!
Maryanne I.
Submitted 07/09/25
Always a pleasant experience
DAVID G.
Submitted 07/08/25
Dr. Taylor Beatty, Dr Scott Brotherton and everyone at Orthopedic Specialists. have Brought Life back to me where I could get out and do the things I enjoy like Walking as far as the path went or Dancing to great music until the sun comes up. Before the surgery from a fall that damaged my spine I couldn't walk farther than 1/2 block or stand longer than 5 minutes which is no way to live. Dr. Brotherton took care of my serious hand problem and got me the great positive results I am heading for. I plan on being able to use my guitar hand for a-lot more years.....Orthopedic Specialists Thank You Again!!!!!!!!
Marsha E.
Submitted 07/08/25
Dr. James did a total knee replacement for me. Almost every step was pre-addressed. The surgery and the recovery and the physical therapy were all perfectly timed. I am now a year out and am so glad I had the surgery. I can depend on my knee in all activities!
That’s a great benefit and peace of mind.
Thomas M.
Submitted 07/08/25
So far so good. Real happy with the whole staff
Veronica B.
Submitted 07/08/25
Everyone was friendly and helpful to someone who had never been at Orthopedic before. The X-ray taken was done quickly with no problems and I enjoyed meeting Dr. Taylor and appreciated his explaining every detail and treatment of my problem.
Pamela C.
Submitted 07/05/25
I’ve been a patient at this facility for a long time. Great doctors! Highly recommend!
Gregory R.
Submitted 07/03/25
Dr Brotherton did surgery on my left shoulder a few years ago. Now I'm pain free.
Now I'm going back to have him work on my right shoulder, and there's no one else I'd rather have do it.
Sandra F.
Submitted 07/02/25
Knowledgeable ' efficient and compassionate
Timothy C.
Submitted 07/02/25
Dr. Brotherton was prompt and efficient,Medical staff are very nice. Cortisone shot has not helped yet but hopefully will soon
Jacqueline G.
Submitted 07/02/25
Dr.James is an extraordinary surgeon.
He explains everything that you need to know and answers your questions in depth. He is easy to talk to and encourages you when you worry your
recovery is slower than you expected.
He gives you information about what will
help with your recovery. I always leave
my appointment feeling I am receiving
great care. Dr. James is very compassionate and really listens to your concerns. I highly recommend him to
Anyone who desires an extremely talented surgeon with a wonderful
“Bedside” personality.
Affelda B.
Submitted 07/01/25
Well liked
Thomas H.
Submitted 06/30/25
From initial contact through scheduling, check in, exam, explanation/discussion of findings, arriving at a care plan, and through checkout, this practice is top notch with great doctors and great supporting staff.
STANLEY L.
Submitted 06/30/25
A little nervous about what the diagnosis would be. Ie. Shoulder problem.the staff was upbeat . When Dr. Taylor explained the problem , which was easy to understand . Was much more relaxed. In all was a good choice seeing Dr. Taylor
Irene Z.
Submitted 06/30/25
Dr. Taylor is so great! I have never felt rushed during any of my visits and he addresses all my questions (no matter how dumb they probably are lol). He seems to truly care about making sure my healing is 100%, and for that I am truly grateful. Highly, highly recommend him.
Dayana N.
Submitted 06/30/25
Dr. Boltuch was cordial during the visit; however getting a hold of him or his staff regarding a request for an MRI has been a terrible experience.
They have no customer service. I have called several times and keep getting their voicemail.
No follow up, nobody who I can talk to.
The worst part is my bad still needs care, but obviously there is no caring about his patients very disappointed.
Cathie C.
Submitted 06/29/25
Best orthopedic doctor there is. Takes time with you explains everything to you.
Susan A.
Submitted 06/28/25
Excellent care ,friendly staff
WILLIAM S.
Submitted 06/28/25
All questions answered. Will consider replacing knee this fall